The Prodigal Greek

The Greek crisis through a different prism

Wolfgang Schaeuble and his favourite topic…Greece

with 6 comments

“All of the countries which are in a program, except Greece, which is in a particularly difficult situation, have made remarkable progress. Even though they are not in a program, what Spain and Italy have achieved is grand,” German finance minister Schaeuble said at a conference last Thursday. His statement came just over a week after he told reporters that it is not time to speculate about Greece and it is best to wait for the troika report – something that many in Greece interpreted as a product of the gradual restoration of the two countries’ relationship after the Greek Prime Minister visited Berlin in August. But the German finance minister seems incapable of helping himself when there is an opportunity to brand Greece a “special case” that has failed to make the progress that the official sector creditors expect.

Schaeuble has first hand information on the intense negotiations between the Greek government and the troika, the divide in the discussions as a result of the troika’s insistence that 9 billion of the 13.5 billion euros come from “hard” measures – mostly cuts to pensions and social welfare – and the tension that is surfacing on a daily basis in the streets of Athens from small scale protests of groups ranging from shipyard workers to people with special needs who see their lives deteriorating due to months of unpaid wages or loss of disability benefits.  The German finance minister must be well informed about the rise of an ultra nationalist party that on Friday staged and filmed scenes of tension in the Greek Parliament, thereby dealing another blow to the already battered political system in Greece.

Surely there is no one more informed than him about the fact that in just three years and for the first time in ten years, in 2013 the Greek state will spend less than it actually collects, achieving a primary surplus in the region of 2 billion, before debt servicing costs. Debt servicing costs that he partly guarantees so Germany included receives uninterrupted interest payments for the loans to Greece as part of the first ‘bailout’ program.

Despite this 360 degrees view of the situation, his choice was again to single out Greece.  Anyone following the Greek crisis is aware that large part of the European discontent supposedly comes from the lack of progress on what they call structural reforms. Surprising though, given the importance that German politicians have very vocally placed on the commitments to the structural aspect of the Greek program, Greece’s creditors never had any qualms about massaging quarterly reviews in such ways that delay in the reforms implementation would not jeopardise the disbursement of bailout tranches, which would lead to a messy default.  They never held Greece’s political establishment truly accountable for the restructuring of the public sector, the opening of closed professions or the modernisation of the business environment.

They would always turn a blind eye to the significant distortions of the Greek economic model and administration – distortions that hinder any implementation success or driver for growth – but would show their steely determination instead on the fiscal aspect, the labour market and wages. There is strict conditionality regarding those aspects, which is always linked to a favourable review or, even most critically, the agreement of the second program and the successful completion of the PSI.

In the areas of the creditors’ true interest, what Greece has achieved should be deemed “grand” by Schaeuble’s standards. The scale of fiscal consolidation is phenomenal and unprecedented during a depression that by the end of the year will have wiped out one fifth of the country’s economy and has one in four Greeks without a job.  On the wages front, Greece is the only country in the EU that sets the national minimum wage by presidential decree as dictated by the government’s compliance with the troika’s requests. The situation is so extreme that all employers’ groups are calling for a rise to the minimum wage, repeatedly stressing that wages are not the hindering factor to competiveness in prices. At the same time, Greece at the moment must have the most elastic labour market in Europe where companies can sign company level agreements containing very limited conditions with their employees below the sector wage agreement and movement of employees is effectively unrestricted with the ability to fire and hire at very low cost. Furthermore, the troika is insisting and will probably get a further 30% reduction to severance pay and the shortening of the notice periods. Greece’s labour market is so ‘reformed’ that according to the Labour Inspection Office 400’000 employees in 120’000 companies across the country have not been paid their wages for more than three months.

With regards to the two key objectives of the troika: fiscal belt tightening – so the creditors don’t finance Greece’s excessive deficit; and the IMF signature “internal devaluation” strategy – through the suppression of incomes with the aim of narrowing the current account deficit – three successive Greek governments should be considered star pupils. Even the current government has been arm wrestled into the implementation of approximately 9 billion euros of spending cuts – close to 5% of GDP – next year, thereby pretty much negating its key strategy of extending the fiscal consolidation period to 2016.

One could potentially assume that Schaeuble’s comments are just a continuation of his, and other northern Europeans, view of moral hazard since the start of the debt crisis. However, even if that were the case, his recent radio silence with regards to Portugal’s one-year extension to achieve its program targets, just highlights that he is not impartial.  Even last night, in a televised interview with ZDF he mentioned that he will remind colleagues at an annual IMF meeting that reducing budget deficits “You have to do that step-by-step in a growth friendly manner”.  Greece is a “unique case” in his own mind and he seems to have a crystallised view that the country still has to be penalised for the ‘sins’ of the past.  Although he has full knowledge that, with all its flaws, if this coalition government fails Greece could fall into a political, social and economic void, he insists on turning the screw on Greece and its people.

It is evident that the German finance minister is just fed up with Greece and if his ideology of the ‘weakest link’ that once dropped will make the euro chain stronger had prevailed early in the summer – it took the intervention of the US and China for him to back off – Greece would have been escorted to the exit by now. Most worryingly, Schaeuble’s views reflect those of many in certain circles within the German coalition that remain ignorant enough to believe that a Greek exit is the solution to the problem. Given that Germany is soon entering an election year, these coalition dynamics will require a balancing act from Chancellor Angela Merkel to keep her government together and design her election strategy.

As much as Schaeuble’s theory of excluding Greece has for now lost out to more sensible voices who have responsibly evaluated the risks of contagion, there should be no doubt that he will keep up the pressure and push the coalition and the Greek society to the brink through his tough stance on negotiations and demands for further austerity.

Those in Greece’s political establishment that celebrate the PR points and expect to get a boost from Merkel’s visit on Tuesday better keep this in mind.



Written by Yiannis Mouzakis

October 8, 2012 at 9:01 am

6 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Excellent post!


    October 8, 2012 at 2:12 pm

    • This is the best and cristal clear picture & article i have read since long !!
      Furthermore Schaueble has been in contradiction over the last week with his statements on Greece when he was travelling to conferences in Singapore and the rest of South East Asia.He loves to be in the limelight!
      The only clear statement made was “We will wait for the troika report, before taking any decision” . But unfortunately for Schaueble one of the troika partners namely the IMF made already up it`s mind and states through Lagarde that a 3rd haircut is a must to be swallowed by the EU/EURO members alone !!!… because the Troika in the first place let Greece hang for 3 years high & dry cutting through austerity measures; thereby bringing GDP down with 20% and 25% unemployment !!!
      Although the good thing is the frau Merkel is running the show and this lame duck ( literally ) will hopefully best leave office … after the September elections in 2013 to be replaced by Steinmayer . Let`s hope & pray Schaueble will not do more damage in the near future !!!ECB can sell its Greek bonds ( 60 billion ) bought at 25% discount to the EMS and Greece can obtain some hard cash from the EU to buy back a serious part of its outstanding debt at market value thereby bringing this unsustainable debt back to realistic proportions !

      Lenaerts Paul

      November 1, 2012 at 12:58 pm

      • This is from a Swedish interested reader. I accidentally stumbled on this blog after trailing an article on the FT about the “Lagarde list”, then over to the Ekathmerini and eventually to this blog. In the hope of news that you Greeks start chasing the corrupt elite (instead of the editor on trial). Instead, I found this poor piece self-pitying crap. How incredibly ungrateful and cynical. You have received an unprecedented amount of help from the Germans and other Euro-members. I am astounded by the patience and generousity from the Northern creditors. STILL, you have the nerve to point fingers at the creditors. You miserably beggars. GROW UP! Start organise yourselves, start WORKING!!!

        angry bird

        November 2, 2012 at 12:14 am

      • From an interested reader I would expect a more constructive contribution to the debate instead of just spouting unfounded stereotypes that borderline offensive.
        Nonetheless, it reflects a minority of the misinformed public opinion and as much as I could have deleted the comment it gets published.

        Yiannis Mouzakis

        November 5, 2012 at 8:34 am

  2. My Swedish friend from the North is making a small mistake in turning his drivel to another european from the North please note the writer/ commentator is of Dutch origine; living in Greece for the last 6 years having a better inside/view on Hellas; that’s the least one can say! So leave the Greeks out and temper your voice and dito populist comments about Greeks who don’t work … etc .
    What i was willing to say was :
    – Mr Schaueble will have to swallow his statements whenever he likes it or not in the coming week… that was the message loud and clear and please note that a lot of Europeans from the North and the South are of the same opinion that the Germans are trying by all means to win time and are not willing to give one euro cent to Greece although Mme Merkel forced the Private Investors/banks to forgive 100 billion 2 years ago !!! Why is Schauble & Merkel now doing nothing … because they are afraid of their voters in 2013 who might turn agaist them!!. If these elections would not have to take place next year the 3rd haircut would have passed months ago and the poor Greek population including pensioners ( with not even 400 to max 600 euro’s a month income ) would have been spared!!!
    Persons like you should be happy to live in Sweden for which we do not blame you !!! … but populist tend to throw everything together making one big hogwash …Remember the Nazi’s blamed everybody in the 30 ties and we learned shortly after what happened!!! After WO II the Americans through Marshall forgave this German Heimat crowd all debts in one go !! History should not be forgotten and it is not for some corrupt Greek politicians & businessmen that all Greeks can go to hell in your doubtful opinion !!! That’s the message not your bla bla bla !!!

    Lenaerts Paul

    November 2, 2012 at 1:08 pm

  3. If you understand that Schauble’s problem is with the Greek government and not the Greek people his position makes total sense. Given that the Greek people believe their government wastes their money and that they are corrupt and given that Schauble believes the same thing I am struggling to comprehend why Greeks are against Merkel and Schauble. Surely the enemy of my enemy is my friend?


    December 4, 2012 at 12:26 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: